Harley-Davidson’s competitive position as one of the main players in the chopper/custom motorcycle market is linked to the ability to respond to the Five Forces in the industry environment. Michael Porter’s Five Forces analysis examines the external factors that affect business strategy and development. In Harley-Davidson’s case, the motorcycle industry presents challenges that can hamper global business growth. The company has maintained a conservative stance toward global expansion. In this regard, business stability is emphasized in Harley-Davidson’s strategy in addressing the Five Forces affecting its business environment. However, strategic reform is needed to ensure that Harley-Davidson overcomes these external factors while the business seeks to improve its international performance.
This Five Forces analysis of Harley-Davidson reveals competitive rivalry and the bargaining power of customers as the most significant external forces that affect the motorcycle industry. These forces are among the strategic priorities for the fulfillment of business goals and Harley-Davidson’s mission statement and vision statement.
Summary & Recommendations: Porter’s Five Forces Analysis of Harley-Davidson
This Five Forces analysis of Harley-Davidson requires consideration for the external factors in the motorcycle industry, as well as the automotive industry. The company is stable despite challenges in the motorcycle market. The following are the intensities or strengths of the Five Forces affecting Harley-Davidson:
- Competitive rivalry or competition: Strong force
- Bargaining power of buyers or customers: Strong force
- Bargaining power of suppliers: Weak force
- Threat of substitutes or substitution: Moderate force
- Threat of new entrants or new entry: Moderate force
Recommendations. Based on this Five Forces analysis, the goals and objectives of Harley-Davidson’s generic competitive strategy and intensive growth strategies need to focus on counteracting the effects of the strong force of competition and the strong bargaining power of customers. For example, Harley-Davidson can increase product development efforts, along with investment in technological innovation. The external factors in this Five Forces analysis also point to the limited but significant effects of the threat of substitution and the threat of new entrants in the motorcycle industry environment. Harley-Davidson can address these concerns through strategic alliances, market penetration, and global expansion.
Competitive Rivalry or Competition with Harley-Davidson (Strong Force)
Harley-Davidson’s strategies account for competition. This part of the Five Forces analysis identifies other companies’ impact in the motorcycle industry. In Harley-Davidson’s case, the following are the external factors that create the strong force of competitive rivalry:
- High number of firms (strong force)
- High availability of substitutes (strong force)
- Moderate variety of motorcycle companies (moderate force)
Harley-Davidson competes with a considerably large number of local and multinational firms, like Yamaha, Ducati, BMW, and Honda. Also, Harley-Davidson faces effective substitutes, such as private cars and public transportation. The moderate variety of competitors contributes to the force of competition because many customers value product features and uniqueness. Based on the external factors in this part of the Five Forces analysis, the motorcycle company must maintain competitiveness, especially in terms of product quality, to protect its business from other firms. The competencies noted in the SWOT analysis of Harley-Davidson address this need for competitiveness. Also, this Five Forces analysis shows that the motorcycle business needs to implement an effective marketing approach to gain and retain more customers. This need relating to the marketing strategy is addressed through improvements in Harley-Davidson’s marketing mix (4P).
Bargaining Power of Harley-Davidson’s Customers/Buyers (Strong Force)
Customers are a factor in Harley-Davidson’s business performance. This part of the Five Forces analysis outlines the external factors that enable consumers or buyers to influence the motorcycle industry. The following external factors contribute to the strong bargaining power of Harley-Davidson’s customers:
- High substitute availability (strong force)
- High quality of information on vehicles and transportation options (strong force)
- Customers’ moderate switching costs (moderate force)
Easy access to substitutes imposes a strong force against Harley-Davidson. Also, the external factor of moderate switching costs enables customers to move away from Harley-Davidson and use substitutes and other products instead. Moreover, companies in the motorcycle industry provide high-quality information to customers to empower them to make better purchasing decisions. In this part of the Five Forces analysis, it is shown that customers are a major force in Harley-Davidson’s industry environment. However, societal factors affect this force. The market and industry trends noted in the PESTEL/PESTLE analysis of Harley-Davidson influence customer perception and decisions. Thus, this part of the Five Forces analysis highlights the importance of aligning strategies to the factors that empower motorcycle buyers.
Bargaining Power of Harley-Davidson’s Suppliers (Weak Force)
Suppliers affect Harley-Davidson in terms of the sufficiency of materials used for its business. This part of the Five Forces analysis tackles how suppliers influence the motorcycle industry. In Harley-Davidson’s case, the following external factors create the weak bargaining power of suppliers:
- Suppliers’ low forward integration (weak force)
- High supply stability (weak force)
- Moderate size of suppliers of materials and components for motorcycle manufacturing (moderate force)
Harley-Davidson’s suppliers are weak because they have minimal forward integration. This means that the suppliers have low control over the distribution and sale of their products to companies, like Harley-Davidson. Also, because of the high stability of supply, individual suppliers have low leverage in imposing their demands on Harley-Davidson. Only the moderate size of some suppliers enables them to have a moderate effect on the company. Based on the external factors in this part of the Five Forces analysis, Harley-Davidson can safely attribute low priority to the bargaining power of suppliers. Nonetheless, suppliers’ needs influence corporate citizenship and related strategic objectives. Thus, the supplier-related factors in this part of the Five Forces analysis are considerations in Harley-Davidson’s CSR and ESG strategy and stakeholder management programs.
Threat of Substitutes or Substitution against Harley-Davidson (Moderate Force)
Harley-Davidson’s business performance partly depends on the effects of substitutes on customers’ behaviors and related sales. This part of the Five Forces analysis indicates how substitute products influence the motorcycle industry environment. The following external factors lead to the moderate threat of substitution against Harley-Davidson:
- Customers’ moderate switching costs (moderate force)
- Moderate substitute variety (moderate force)
- High substitute availability (strong force)
There are many substitutes for Harley-Davidson’s products. For example, cars and public transportation are available. This part of the Five Forces analysis indicates that the motorcycle market is under some influence from automotive companies, like Ford, Tesla, Toyota, and General Motors. This condition exerts a strong force on Harley-Davidson. However, the overall threat of substitution against the company is only moderate because customers who are really into using chopper motorcycles are less likely to readily shift from Harley-Davidson to such substitutes. Also, the moderate substitute variety makes substitutes have a significant but limited attractiveness. This part of the Five Forces analysis shows that Harley-Davidson must include the moderate force of the threat of substitution as a significant concern in strategic formulation.
Threat of New Entrants or New Entry against Harley-Davidson (Moderate Force)
New entrants can reduce Harley-Davidson’s customer base and market share. This part of the Five Forces analysis determines the potential effects of new firms on Harley-Davidson and the motorcycle industry. The moderate force of the threat of new entry is based on the following external factors:
- Moderate economies of scale (moderate force)
- Customers’ moderate switching costs (moderate force)
- High cost of motorcycle brand development (weak force)
Harley-Davidson benefits from moderate economies of scale. Only some new entrants can easily achieve the same benefit. Also, Harley-Davidson must consider moderate switching costs, which means that it is moderately easy for customers to shift to other brands or companies. However, the high cost of brand development is an entry barrier that prevents many new entrants from successfully competing against Harley-Davidson. As shown in this part of the Five Forces analysis, Harley-Davidson must address the threat of new entrants as a considerable issue in the motorcycle industry.
References
- Aggarwal, A., Baker, H. K., & Joshi, N. A. (2024). Organizational innovation as business strategy: A review and bibliometric analysis. Journal of the Knowledge Economy, 1-27.
- Bykov, N. V., & Kostrov, M. A. (2024). Social dilemmas in a mixed traffic flow of buses and personal vehicles in transport mode choice. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 647, 129873.
- Harley-Davidson, Inc. – Form 10-K.
- Harley-Davidson, Inc. – Our Strategy.
- Wada, Y., Bizen, Y., Isaka, T., & Hayakawa, T. (2024). Exploring the components of “Kando” and the factors evoking it during motorcycle riding. Transportation Research Interdisciplinary Perspectives, 25, 101104.